trelvane
100% Free Forever 100% Private · Inputs Never Saved No Sign-Up Required

Roth 401(k) vs. Traditional Pre-Tax 401(k) Tax Arbitrage Calculator

Compare immediate Federal + State paycheck tax savings from a Pre-Tax Traditional 401(k) against 100% tax-free retirement withdrawals from a Roth 401(k) or Roth IRA.

✓ SECURE 2.0 Super Catch-Up Ready
Current Age
Retire At Age
Current 401(k) ($)
Annual Salary ($)
Your 401(k) ($16,200/yr)
%
Company Match Cap (%)
%
Your US State:

• Contributing $16,200/yr to a Pre-Tax Traditional 401(k) in California cuts your immediate Federal + State tax bill by $5,335/yr (so your net take-home pay only drops by $10,865/yr).

Calculating...
Projected Retirement Nest Egg at Age 62
$5,531,044$3,196,378 in Today's $
Safe 4% Monthly Income (Today's Purchasing Power)$10,655 / mo
Safe 4% Monthly Income (Nominal Future Dollars)$18,437 / mo
Starting Balance + Your Contributions$1,064,118
Total Free Employer Match Collected+$195,009
Total Compound Investment Growth+$4,271,918
Coast FIRE Milestone
Age 50
$1,000,000 Milestone Age
Age 45 (2041)
2026 IRS Cap Check: Your max allowed employee 401(k) deferral at Age 30 is $24,500/yr.

401(k) Savings Rate vs. Retirement Nest Egg Comparison (Age 30 → 62)

See how increasing your employee 401(k) contribution percentage from 6% to 20% on a $135,000 salary accelerates your retirement nest egg and $1M milestone age:

Your 401(k) % Nominal Nest Egg Today's Purchasing Power 4% Safe Income (Today $) $1M Milestone Age
6% (+6% Match) $2,885,898 $1,637,490 $5,458 / mo Age 51
10% (+6% Match) $3,911,991 $2,254,325 $7,514 / mo Age 48
15% (+6% Match) $4,963,593 $2,857,121 $9,524 / mo Age 46
20% (+6% Match) $5,161,513 $2,948,825 $9,829 / mo Age 46

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the 2026 SECURE 2.0 Mandatory Roth Catch-Up rule for high earners? ▾

Starting in 2026 under IRC § 414(v)(7), if you earned more than $145,000 in FICA wages from your employer in the prior year, any age 50+ catch-up contributions ($8,000 or $11,250) must be made as Roth (after-tax) contributions rather than pre-tax.